Letter, vindicating Balmerino, in a certain Point, to a Gentleman in Holland
Metadata
Titles
Table of Contents
Letter, vindicating Balmerino, in a 
                        certain Point, to a Gentleman in Holland
Forbes
Copy of a Letter to a Gentleman in Holland, vindicating the Character of Arthur, Lord Balmerino, in a certain important Point.
Steuart
Letter vindicating Balmerino, in a certain point, to a gentleman in Holland
Paton
Letter to a gentleman in Holland, vindicating the character of Arthur, Lord Balmerino, in a certain important point
Pages
Forbes
Vol. 1, 114—116Paton
Vol. 1, 58—60Credits
Encoder (metadata)
Transcriber
Proofreader
Proofreader
Encoder
Encoder
Status
Document
Metadata
Notes
Walkinshaw indicates that Lady Balmerino had some input with this letter.
Correspondence
sent
| Person | John Walkinshaw | 
| Date | 05 Sep 1746 | 
| Place | London | 
| Place | 
received
| Person | Gentleman in Holland | 
| Place | Holland | 
acknowledgements
compliments to
enclosed in
enclosures
requests
Walkinshaw asks the recipient to pass his letter on to “the proper Person” to make a retraction in the Amsterdam Gazette, as well as (possibly the same person) “the First Person of so great a Republick”.
remediation
in Forbes
Related Documents
Passive:
                                
Wednesday's Afternoon, Septr 9th, 1747 at the Hour appointed (4 o'Clock) Ned Bourk came to my Room, when I went through his Journal with him at great Leisure, and, from his own Mouth, made those Passages plain & intelligible, that were written in confused indistinct Terms. (v02.0326.01): Mentioned in footnote
Transcription
Copy of a Letter to a Gentleman
			
in Holland, vindicating the Charac-
ter of Arthur, Lord Balmerino,
			
in a certain important Point.
DrDear Sir,
I have not yet been able to an-
swer the Cries of the Officers for beating
Orders, &and I can conceive no other Reason for
our Ministry’s refusing them, than that of yethe
young Chevalier's being in Scotland, &and that
they thought, that his Escape might have been
saved through their Means; but now that he
is safe arrived in France, I hope, that we
shall meet with no more Difficulties.
      	
			swer the Cries of the Officers for beating
Orders, &and I can conceive no other Reason for
our Ministry’s refusing them, than that of yethe
young Chevalier's being in Scotland, &and that
they thought, that his Escape might have been
saved through their Means; but now that he
is safe arrived in France, I hope, that we
shall meet with no more Difficulties.
I had the Honour to be of Lord Bal-
merino’s Acquaintance; &and it was my Mis-
fortune to be pitched upon to attend upon
him in the Tower, at his last Moments, &and
upon the Scaffold, where I was Witness to
a Behaviour, that even exceeded all that we 115 (115)
we read of in the Heroes of Antiquity. His
whole Behaviour was so composed, so decent,
that it greatly surprizedsurprised the Sheriffs, the
Clergymen, his Friends, &and the Spectators; &and
at the same Time not a Soldier present,
but was moved by his Intrepidity.
      	
			merino’s Acquaintance; &and it was my Mis-
fortune to be pitched upon to attend upon
him in the Tower, at his last Moments, &and
upon the Scaffold, where I was Witness to
a Behaviour, that even exceeded all that we 115 (115)
we read of in the Heroes of Antiquity. His
whole Behaviour was so composed, so decent,
that it greatly surprizedsurprised the Sheriffs, the
Clergymen, his Friends, &and the Spectators; &and
at the same Time not a Soldier present,
but was moved by his Intrepidity.
My Lady Balmerino is now at my Elbow,
			
&and She has desired me to write to your Heer
PensrPensionary, that She is greatly offended at
a Passage in your Amsterdam Gazette of
Tuesday, SeptrSeptember 6th, 1746, where, in giving ^an
Account of that Lord’s unhappy End, the Au-
thor is so insolent as to insert so notorious
a FalshoodFalsehood, that it can in no Sort be justi-
fied. He has no Authority from My Lord,
from the Sheriffs, from the Clergymen,
nor even from our lying News Papers.
      	
			&and She has desired me to write to your Heer
PensrPensionary, that She is greatly offended at
a Passage in your Amsterdam Gazette of
Tuesday, SeptrSeptember 6th, 1746, where, in giving ^an
Account of that Lord’s unhappy End, the Au-
thor is so insolent as to insert so notorious
a FalshoodFalsehood, that it can in no Sort be justi-
fied. He has no Authority from My Lord,
from the Sheriffs, from the Clergymen,
nor even from our lying News Papers.
The Government here had a Power over
			
his Body, &and he has suffered for his Rebel-
lion; but neither they, nor their Agents
abroad, have any just Power over his
Reputation. — ’Tis barbarous to the great-
est Degree, &and lays us under a Necessity,
let the Consequences be w^hat they will,
to give you My Lord's own Words on ytthat
Point; a Point, which he had greatly at
Heart to clear up; &and they are, as follows.
      	
			his Body, &and he has suffered for his Rebel-
lion; but neither they, nor their Agents
abroad, have any just Power over his
Reputation. — ’Tis barbarous to the great-
est Degree, &and lays us under a Necessity,
let the Consequences be w^hat they will,
to give you My Lord's own Words on ytthat
Point; a Point, which he had greatly at
Heart to clear up; &and they are, as follows.
“I have heard, since I came to this
			
[“]Place, that there has been a most wicked
[“]Report spread, &and mentioned in several of
[“]the News Papers; That his Royal Highness,
[“]the Prince, before the Battle of Culloden,
[“]had given out in Orders, that no Quarters should 116 (116)
“should be given to the Enemy. This is such
“an unchristian Thing, &and so unlike that gal-
“lant Prince, that no Bodynoboy, that knows him,
“will believe it. It is very strange, if
“there had been any such Orders, that nei-
“ther the Earl of Kilmarnock, who was
“Colonel of the Regiment of Foot-Guards,
“nor I, who was Colonel of the 2d Troop
“of Life-Guards, should never have heard
“any Thinganything of it, especially since we were
“both at the Head Quarters the Morning be-
“fore the Battle. I am convinced, that it
“is a malicious Report, industriously spread
“to excuse themselves for the Murders they
“were guilty of in calm Blood after yethe Battle.”
      	
			[“]Place, that there has been a most wicked
[“]Report spread, &and mentioned in several of
[“]the News Papers; That his Royal Highness,
[“]the Prince, before the Battle of Culloden,
[“]had given out in Orders, that no Quarters should 116 (116)
“should be given to the Enemy. This is such
“an unchristian Thing, &and so unlike that gal-
“lant Prince, that no Bodynoboy, that knows him,
“will believe it. It is very strange, if
“there had been any such Orders, that nei-
“ther the Earl of Kilmarnock, who was
“Colonel of the Regiment of Foot-Guards,
“nor I, who was Colonel of the 2d Troop
“of Life-Guards, should never have heard
“any Thinganything of it, especially since we were
“both at the Head Quarters the Morning be-
“fore the Battle. I am convinced, that it
“is a malicious Report, industriously spread
“to excuse themselves for the Murders they
“were guilty of in calm Blood after yethe Battle.”
I shall take ^it as a very great Favour,
			
if you are so kind, as to lay the Above be-
fore the proper Person, whose Authority it
is to take Cognizance of it, that he may
be obliged to retract, in the most solemn
Manner, a FalshoodFalsehood, uttered to the Preju-
dice of the Reputation of one of yethe great-
estof men that ever was born, let
			
his Principles have been what they will.
It is My Lady Balmerino's Desire; it is
mine, as his Friend, &and as a Friend to
Truth and Justice.
      	
			if you are so kind, as to lay the Above be-
fore the proper Person, whose Authority it
is to take Cognizance of it, that he may
be obliged to retract, in the most solemn
Manner, a FalshoodFalsehood, uttered to the Preju-
dice of the Reputation of one of yethe great-
est
his Principles have been what they will.
It is My Lady Balmerino's Desire; it is
mine, as his Friend, &and as a Friend to
Truth and Justice.
I dare not presume to write to so great a
			
Man as the first Person of so great a Re-
publick: Therefore I beg, that you will lay
it before him, &and you will very much oblige,
      	
			Man as the first Person of so great a Re-
publick: Therefore I beg, that you will lay
it before him, &and you will very much oblige,
DrDear Sir,
London, 5/16 SeptrSeptember,
			    
1746.
1746.
Citation
Forbes, Robert. “Copy of a Letter to a Gentleman in Holland, vindicating the Character of Arthur, Lord Balmerino, in a certain important Point.” The Lyon in Mourning, 
                    vol. 1, 
                    Adv.MS.32.6.16, fol. 69v–70v. The Lyon in Mourning Project, 
                    edited by Leith Davis, https://lyoninmourning.dhil.lib.sfu.ca/ v01.0114.01.html.