Go to homepage
  • Go to homepage
  • About
    • About the Project
    • Background
    • Team
    • Project CV
    • Acknowledgments
  • Volumes
    • Vol. 1 (1-198)
    • Vol. 2 (199-380)
    • Vol. 3 (381-624)
    • Vol. 4 (625-868)
    • Vol. 5 (869-1112)
    • Vol. 6 (1113-1356)
    • Vol. 7 (1357-1598)
    • Vol. 8 (1599-1840)
    • Vol. 9 (1841-2114)
    • Vol. 10 (2115-2149)
    • Vol. 11 (index)
  • Genres
    • Account / narrative
    • Additional material
    • Contents
    • Conversation
    • Insert
    • Letter
    • Miscellaneous
    • Poem / song / epitaph
    • Speech
    • Title page
  • Networks
    • People
    • Organizations
    • Places
    • Events
  • Search
Vol. 3
Conversation
Previous
Journal of Miss Flora MacDonald, etc.
Next
Townly's Ghost, etc. a Song

Some Questions proposed to Miss MacDonald and her answers to them

Metadata
Titles
Table of Contents
Some Questions proposed to Miss MacDonald & her answers to them
Steuart
Some questions proposed to Miss MacDonald & her answers to them
Pages
Forbes
Vol. 3, 541—544
Paton
Vol. 1, 304—306
Credits
Encoder (metadata)
Kaitlyn MacInnis
Transcriber
Julianna Wagar
Proofreader
Leith Davis
Proofreader
Kaitlyn MacInnis
Encoder
Genevieve Bourjeaurd
Encoder
Kaitlyn MacInnis
Status
Document
transcription proofed
Metadata
metadata in progress
Notes
Forbes's N.B. giving context for this item is on pp. 540-41. Forbes gave Dr Burton questions in writing for Flora MacDonald, and Dr Burton “procure[d] direct Answers to them.”. It isn't clear whether Flora delivered the answers orally or in writing.
An N.B. on p. 544 gives Forbes's account of Flora's transfer to London.
Settings
Date
Time
Occasion
Person (main)
Person (participant)
Place
original medium
remediation
in Forbes
Related Documents
Active:
Journal of Donald MacLeod, &c. (v02.0266.01): Mentions in footnote
A particular Narrative anent Armadale taken from Captain John Hay at Air (v03.0458.01): Mentions in footnote
Journal of Miss Flora MacDonald, etc. (v03.0524.01): Mentions in transcription
Passive:
Journal of Miss Flora MacDonald, etc. (v03.0524.01): Mentioned in metadata
Transcription
541
Question 1st. Ask particularly at Miss
MacDonald
, by what lucky Accident it
came about, that She &and Captain O Neil
had a Meeting at first to concert Mea-
sures
? whether or not it was by the
Direction of ^her Stepfather, Armadale, or of any
other Person? For as O Neil was an
entire Stranger in the Country, this is
a material Question, &and must remain
a Mystery till Miss clears it up.
Answer. When the Prince &and his few
Friends were skulking in the Long Isle,
O Neil used to scour about frequently
by himself to try what he could learn,
&and this led him to be several Times at
Milton, before he made the Proposal
to Miss MacDonald, as they were then
skulking thereabouts. O Neil, by being
free &and easy with Miss &and her Brother,
came soon to learn their History, &and that
their Mother lived in Sky, &cetc.
2. Ask particularly, if Armadale had
any private Meeting (in Person) with yethe
Prince, while skulking; for it is certain,
that General Campbell✝ complained, ytthat
Armadale was the Person, who had misled
him when searching for the young
Pretender
in the Long Isle.
AAnswer: When the Prince first landed upon
the Continent of Scotland, Armadale, hap-
pening
to be on the Continent, was walk-
ing
upon the Shore, just as the Prince &and
his Friends were sailing towards it. Arma-dale

✝
See Pag: 458, 459 in this Vol:
542(542)
dale, spying a Sail making towards the
very Spot, upon which he was walking,
stoptstopped, till he should learn what the
Ship was, &and from whence she had come.
When the Prince steptstepped ashore, Armadale
was the first Man, that took him by yethe
Hand &and kissed it; for he was introduced
to the Prince by those that were along
with him. The Prince &and Armadale con-
versed
some time together. Soon after ysthis,
Armadale returned to the Isle of Sky, &and
never saw the Prince again, either be-
fore
, or in, the Time of his skulking.
3. ✝It is said, that Armadale writ a
Letter, which he sent by Miss MacDo-
nald
to her Mother, recommending yethe
Irish Girl, Bettie Burk, as a good ser-
vant
, &and giving an Account of her good
Qualifications as such. It were to be
wished, that Miss could recollect the
Contents of said Letter as exactly as
possible, in order to give a Narrative
of the same.
AAnswer: The Substance of the Writing, qchwhich
Armadale sent to his Wife, was, as is
already mentioned in Miss MacDonald’s
own Journal. See P: 525 in this Vol:
4. Ask what particular Songs he chaun-
ted
in crossing from the Long Isle to
Sky? if she can give the Names of them.
AAnswer: He sung, The King shall enjoy
his own again
, and, The twenty Ninth of

✝
Vol: 2. pag: 304, 305.
543 (543)
of May, &cetc.
5. Ask, whether or not Lady Clanra-
nald
furnished the Prince &and Miss Mac-
Donald
with some Bottles, full of
Milk, as part of their provisions on
Board the Boat in the Passage to
Sky? and, whether or not the Prince
did put the Bottle to his Head, &and
drink in common with those on
Board?
AAnswer: Lady Clanronald did furnish them
with some Bottles of Milk, &and the
Prince (in the Passage) putting the
Bottle to his Head, drank in com-
mon
with those on Board Jock-fel-
low-like
.1 Lady Clanronald had
but one Half-bottle of Wine (there
having been so many Demands u-
pon
her, particularly from Parties
of the Military) which she likewise
caused ^to be put on Board the Boat.
The Prince, in the Passage, would
not allow any Person to share in
this small Allowance of Wine; but
kept it altogether for Miss MacDo-
nald
's Use, lest she should faint
with the Cold &and other Inconvenien-
cies
, of a Night-passage.
6. To the preceedingpreceding Questions DrDoctor Bur-
ton
was pleased to add one of his own, which 544 (544)
which is, What Length of Time there
happened to be betwixt the Prince’s leav-
ing
Kingsburgh's House, &and Captain Fer-
guson
's
coming thither to search for him?
AAnswer: About six or seven Days; so ytthat
the Prince behoved, by that Time, to be
actually upon the Continent.
N: B: Miss Flora MacDonald was,
upon the 28th of Novr,November, 1746, put on B^oard
the Royal Sovereign lying at the Nore, &and
upon yethe 6th of DecrDecember following, was re-
moved
to London, &and put into the Custo-
dy
of Mr Dick, a Messenger, in whose
Hands were likewise DrDoctor Burton, Ӕneas
MacDonald
, Malcolm MacLeod, Clan-
ronald
Senior
, Boisdale, &c.etc. but Lady Clan-
ronald
was not allowed to be in the
same Messenger's House with her
Husband
.
Robert Forbes, A: M:

Townley's
Downloads
Download XML Download manuscript images as PDF
Citation
Forbes, Robert. “Some questions proposed to Miss MacDonald & her answers to them.” The Lyon in Mourning, vol. 3, Adv.MS.32.6.18, fol. 82r–83v. The Lyon in Mourning Project, edited by Leith Davis, https://lyoninmourning.dhil.lib.sfu.ca/v03.0541.01.html.
Appendix
I.e., comradely.
Kaitlyn MacInnis

Version: 1.0.0b. Last built: September 26, 2025 @ 10:56am (revision a7293ed).