Copy of a Paper relative to the Beginning of the Troubles, wherein of Lord Lovat, President Forbes, Laird of MacLeod, Seaforth, etc
Metadata
Titles
Table of Contents
Copy of a Paper relative to ye Be-
                     ginning of ye Troubles, qrein of Ld 
                        Lovat, President Forbes, Laird of Mac-
                           Leod, Seaforth, &c
Forbes
Copy of a paper relative to the beginning of the troubles, wherein of Lord Lovat, President Forbes, Laird of MacLeod, Seaforth, et cetera
Paton
Papers about Lord Lovat and the Laird of MacLeod
Pages
Forbes
Vol. 5, 883—889Paton
Vol. 2, 83—86Credits
Encoder (metadata)
Transcriber
Proofreader
Proofreader
Encoder
Encoder
Status
Document
Metadata
Settings
| Date | 17 May 1748 | 
| Person | James MacKenzie (an Orkney man) | 
| Place | Edinburgh | 
remediation
in Forbes
Related Documents
Active:
                                
Journal of Donald MacLeod, &c. (v02.0266.01): Mentions in footnote
Journal of the Prince's Imbarkation & Arrival, et cetera the greatest Part of which was taken from Duncan Cameron at several different Conversations I had with him. (v02.0346.01): Mentions in footnote
Journal of Captain Donald MacDonald, alias, Donald Roy (v04.0709.01): Mentions in footnote
Remarkable Saying of President Forbes on
                            his Death-bed to one of his own Relations (v05.0963.01): Mentions in footnote
Another account, anonymous (v06.1333.01): Mentions in footnote
Copy of an Answer to Mr James Hay at
                     Inverness. May 13. 1749. (v06.1347.01): Mentions in footnote
Copy of a Note from the Reverend Mr Hay Inverness. October 20. 49 (v07.1442.01): Mentions in footnote
A Nota Bene containing an extraordinary Particular about President Forbes, in 1746. (v07.1443.01): Mentions in footnote
Passive:
                                
Journal of the Prince's Imbarkation & Arrival, et cetera the greatest Part of which was taken from Duncan Cameron at several different Conversations I had with him. (v02.0346.01): Mentioned in footnote
Journal of Captain Donald MacDonald, alias, Donald Roy (v04.0709.01): Mentioned in footnote
Remarkable Saying of President Forbes on
                            his Death-bed to one of his own Relations (v05.0963.01): Mentioned in footnote
A Nota Bene containing an extraordinary Particular about President Forbes, in 1746. (v07.1443.01): Mentioned in footnote
Account of an Interview and Conversation with Mr James
                     Grant, Merchant in Inverness, Leith, March 7. 1750 (v07.1482.01): Mentioned in transcription
Transcription
Tuesday, May 17th, 1748, being 
			
in the Advocates Library in EdrEdinburgh, 
			
Mr Walter Goodale, Under-keep-
er of the said Library, put into
			
my Hands a Paper, which, he 
			
said, he had forgot to deliver 
				
to BpBishop Keith, as he had promis-
ed to do. After pursuing the 
			
Paper, I asked Mr Goodale 
			
who the Person was, who had 
			
writ it? He answered, one Mr 
			
James MacKenzie (an Orkney-
			
man) Writer in EdrEdinburgh, who 
			
knew these Matters well. I 
			
then asked Mr Goodale, if he 
			
would trust me with the Pap-
er, &and I promised to deliver it 
				
carefully to BpBishop Keith? Upon 
			
that Condition Mr Goodale gave 
			
me the Paper, of which fol-
lows an exact Copy. 
Memorandum for Bp.Bishop Keith.
While the Highlanders were as-
semblingin at Perth, those of west-
Ross (a Mackenzie Country) were im-
patient of the Restraints they lay
under, partly by means of their Chief, a 884 (884)
a man in the Guidance of the late
K.King Duncan, &and partly by means of
the Lord Lovat, of whom they had
been justly mistrustful since the
Year 1715. Week after week (were
they told) his Lop’sLordship’s men were to
move, &and then were they in a Readiness
to follow at his Heels, but
things notwithstanding continu’dcontinued so
long in Inaction, that the Neigh-
bours all about, particularly those
at whom his Lop.Lordship had a Hatred,
took Occasion from thence to sus-
pect his Sincerity, &and to look on
his Professions as a Bait only to
hook them into his Power. Not
that his Lop.Lordship was indeed to be
mistrusted, for without all Doubt
he was ^a Friend of his Country, but
besides his being too easily gull’dgulled
by the Laird of Macleod, a Man
every way unequal to him, he
sought also to act in the Dark,
out of a Scrupulosity perhaps of
hazarding his Estate, which I look
on as the Cause of his long Inaction, a 885 (885)
a thing of more Detriment to the
publickpublic Good than is generally
known.
			sembling
Ross (a Mackenzie Country) were im-
patient of the Restraints they lay
under, partly by means of their Chief, a 884 (884)
a man in the Guidance of the late
K.King Duncan, &and partly by means of
the Lord Lovat, of whom they had
been justly mistrustful since the
Year 1715. Week after week (were
they told) his Lop’sLordship’s men were to
move, &and then were they in a Readiness
to follow at his Heels, but
things notwithstanding continu’dcontinued so
long in Inaction, that the Neigh-
bours all about, particularly those
at whom his Lop.Lordship had a Hatred,
took Occasion from thence to sus-
pect his Sincerity, &and to look on
his Professions as a Bait only to
hook them into his Power. Not
that his Lop.Lordship was indeed to be
mistrusted, for without all Doubt
he was ^a Friend of his Country, but
besides his being too easily gull’dgulled
by the Laird of Macleod, a Man
every way unequal to him, he
sought also to act in the Dark,
out of a Scrupulosity perhaps of
hazarding his Estate, which I look
on as the Cause of his long Inaction, a 885 (885)
a thing of more Detriment to the
publickpublic Good than is generally
known.
Next to Lovats's Irresolution, &and the 
			
general Distrust entertain’dentertained of him
on that Account, the Machinati-
ons of the ✝ Laird of Macleod,
that great Engine of Duncan’sX
Plots, were of unhappy Consequence.
For when the Commonality were
every whereeverywhere gathering, &and in small
Parties marching away to the
Place of Rendezvous, this Deceiv-
er disguis’ddisguised like a Friend, wrought
on their Leaders from time to time
to halt for him &and the Knight of
Mac-DonaldMacDonald, upon a Pretence that
the Mackenzies1 &and they, by marching
in one Body, would bring a Credit
to the young Man’s affairs which
would be lost by repairing to him
in divided Companies. And when
Men at last began to suspect him,
both by reason of his studied Delays,
&and of his frequent Consultations with
Duncan, he sent them a Letter in
Answer to a Remonstrance made to him
			
				886
			(886)
			
him on these Grounds, wherein he
makes Profession of his confirm’dconfirmed
Purpose of arming for his Country,
&and concludes with these words, For
my own Part, I am either at the
Height of my Ambition, or at the
Foot of a Gibbet: A Profession, it
must be own’downed, but too easily trust-
ed, &and so much the more that his
Fidelity had at first been vouch’dvouched
for, by a Messenger sent into these
Parts by the young Man in order
to quicken the Motion of his Friends.
For a Consultation being then held
at Castle Downy, the Traitor so
dissembled his Duty that he out-
witted them all, insomuch that
afterwards, when Men expressed a
Distrust of him, by reason of his
Contrivances to keep things back,
the Messenger (Barrisdale by name)
still gave Assurances as if his
Master had not a truer Friend u-
pon Earth. And as the Notoriety
of his Accession to the Call for
the young Man had gain’dgained him a
Credit with his Neighbours from the 887 (887)
the Beginning, so these Assurances
of the Messenger, together with his
own Protestations both by word &and
writ, serv’dserved as Arguments to en-
creaseincrease the Stock of it, till at
length certain Leaders submitted
Themselves to his Direction, &and
then their Eyes never open’dopened
till they saw him with his Men
at Inverness.
			general Distrust entertain’dentertained of him
on that Account, the Machinati-
ons of the ✝ Laird of Macleod,
that great Engine of Duncan’sX
Plots, were of unhappy Consequence.
For when the Commonality were
every whereeverywhere gathering, &and in small
Parties marching away to the
Place of Rendezvous, this Deceiv-
er disguis’ddisguised like a Friend, wrought
on their Leaders from time to time
to halt for him &and the Knight of
Mac-DonaldMacDonald, upon a Pretence that
the Mackenzies1 &and they, by marching
in one Body, would bring a Credit
to the young Man’s affairs which
would be lost by repairing to him
in divided Companies. And when
Men at last began to suspect him,
both by reason of his studied Delays,
&and of his frequent Consultations with
Duncan, he sent them a Letter in
Answer to a Remonstrance made to him
him on these Grounds, wherein he
makes Profession of his confirm’dconfirmed
Purpose of arming for his Country,
&and concludes with these words, For
my own Part, I am either at the
Height of my Ambition, or at the
Foot of a Gibbet: A Profession, it
must be own’downed, but too easily trust-
ed, &and so much the more that his
Fidelity had at first been vouch’dvouched
for, by a Messenger sent into these
Parts by the young Man in order
to quicken the Motion of his Friends.
For a Consultation being then held
at Castle Downy, the Traitor so
dissembled his Duty that he out-
witted them all, insomuch that
afterwards, when Men expressed a
Distrust of him, by reason of his
Contrivances to keep things back,
the Messenger (Barrisdale by name)
still gave Assurances as if his
Master had not a truer Friend u-
pon Earth. And as the Notoriety
of his Accession to the Call for
the young Man had gain’dgained him a
Credit with his Neighbours from the 887 (887)
the Beginning, so these Assurances
of the Messenger, together with his
own Protestations both by word &and
writ, serv’dserved as Arguments to en-
creaseincrease the Stock of it, till at
length certain Leaders submitted
Themselves to his Direction, &and
then their Eyes never open’dopened
till they saw him with his Men
at Inverness.
In the mean time, Lord Seafort 
			
having resign’dresigned his Will to K.King Dun-
can, was taught to persuade his
Clan that Lovat indeed was arm-
ing for the Government, &and only
watch’dwatched an Opportunity of falling
into their Country, where-ever he
should be furnish’dfurnished with a Pretence
for doing it. And as if a Design
had moreover been form’dformed of sur-
prizingsurprising Seafort himself, upon that
new stock of Disgust betwixt Lovat
&and him, what does he but call in the
Kintail-men to Brahan Castle,
as it were to be a Guard upon his
own Person &and Inland-Estate, but
in Reality, if he could not wile them 888 (888)
them over to the Gathering at In-
verness, yet at least that he might
divert their Inclinations of repair-
ing to the other side. And thothough
in this matter he with great En-
deavours obtain’dobtained what he aim’daimed
at, yet when they understood
his more conceal’dconcealed Designs, they
twitted him to his Teeth2 &and went
home, saying, They knew but one
King, &and if they were not at Li-
berty to fight for him, they would
do it for no other.
			having resign’dresigned his Will to K.King Dun-
can, was taught to persuade his
Clan that Lovat indeed was arm-
ing for the Government, &and only
watch’dwatched an Opportunity of falling
into their Country, where-ever he
should be furnish’dfurnished with a Pretence
for doing it. And as if a Design
had moreover been form’dformed of sur-
prizingsurprising Seafort himself, upon that
new stock of Disgust betwixt Lovat
&and him, what does he but call in the
Kintail-men to Brahan Castle,
as it were to be a Guard upon his
own Person &and Inland-Estate, but
in Reality, if he could not wile them 888 (888)
them over to the Gathering at In-
verness, yet at least that he might
divert their Inclinations of repair-
ing to the other side. And thothough
in this matter he with great En-
deavours obtain’dobtained what he aim’daimed
at, yet when they understood
his more conceal’dconcealed Designs, they
twitted him to his Teeth2 &and went
home, saying, They knew but one
King, &and if they were not at Li-
berty to fight for him, they would
do it for no other.
Macleod’s Men also serv’dserved him much 
			
in this way after their Rout at
Inverury; for when he endeavour-
ed to rally them at Elgin, they
kept him in mind how he had al-
ready deceived them, by making them
believe they were to serve the young
Man when he first brought them out
of the Island; &and afterwards, how to
hold them together at Inverness he
had dissembled with them, as if he
always meant to let them follow
their own Inclinations; till at last
having led them to Inverury a just Dispersion 889 (889)
Dispersion (said they) had there be-
fallen them for his Perfidiousness
to the young Man. And yet (they
told him) wou’dwould he but still return to
his Duty, they would not so much as
look home, for Haste to go with him;
whereas if he continued obstinate,
they would leave him to a Man, which
they did accordingly.
			in this way after their Rout at
Inverury; for when he endeavour-
ed to rally them at Elgin, they
kept him in mind how he had al-
ready deceived them, by making them
believe they were to serve the young
Man when he first brought them out
of the Island; &and afterwards, how to
hold them together at Inverness he
had dissembled with them, as if he
always meant to let them follow
their own Inclinations; till at last
having led them to Inverury a just Dispersion 889 (889)
Dispersion (said they) had there be-
fallen them for his Perfidiousness
to the young Man. And yet (they
told him) wou’dwould he but still return to
his Duty, they would not so much as
look home, for Haste to go with him;
whereas if he continued obstinate,
they would leave him to a Man, which
they did accordingly.
N: B: The above is an excellent
			
Paper, &and contains a true &and most ex-
act Account of Things. The Parti-
culars contained in it have been
frequently affirmed to me by se-
veral Persons. Duncan was very
poorly rewarded for all his Services,
&and very remarkable Ones they were;
for to his Stratagems alone were
owing the small Numbers, that
repaired to the Prince’s Standard.
In a Word, it may be affirmed wtwith
great Truth, that he did more than
all the Rest of the Government
joined together, &and yet he was ne-
glected &and despised. After the Bat-
tle of Culloden he could not obtain
			
one Favour for his poor Country. His O-
pinion of Things vanished into Va-
pour &and Smoke. A Hawley, a Husk, an
Albemarle, or even a Scott, or a Lockheart
was preferred to the long-headed, saga-
cious Dun^can.
 Paper, &and contains a true &and most ex-
act Account of Things. The Parti-
culars contained in it have been
frequently affirmed to me by se-
veral Persons. Duncan was very
poorly rewarded for all his Services,
&and very remarkable Ones they were;
for to his Stratagems alone were
owing the small Numbers, that
repaired to the Prince’s Standard.
In a Word, it may be affirmed wtwith
great Truth, that he did more than
all the Rest of the Government
joined together, &and yet he was ne-
glected &and despised. After the Bat-
tle of Culloden he could not obtain
one Favour for his poor Country. His O-
pinion of Things vanished into Va-
pour &and Smoke. A Hawley, a Husk, an
Albemarle, or even a Scott, or a Lockheart
was preferred to the long-headed, saga-
cious Dun^can.
Robert Forbes A:M
Citation
Forbes, Robert. “Copy of a paper relative to the beginning of the troubles, wherein of Lord Lovat, President Forbes, Laird of MacLeod, Seaforth, et cetera.” The Lyon in Mourning, 
                    vol. 5, 
                    Adv.MS.32.6.20, fol. 10r–13r. The Lyon in Mourning Project, 
                    edited by Leith Davis, https://lyoninmourning.dhil.lib.sfu.ca/ v05.0883.01.html.
Appendix
Perhaps meaning Earl of Cromartie's Regiment.