Copy of a Letter from the Reverend Mr George Innes, March 15. 1748/9. and of a Narrative, etc.
Metadata
Titles
Table of Contents
Copy of a Letter from the R: Mr George Innes, March 15. 1748/9. & of a Narrative, &c.
Steuart
Copy of a Letter from the Reverend Mr. George
            Innes, March 15. 1748/9, and of a narrative et cetera
Paton
Letter from Rev. George Innes, in Forres
Pages
Forbes
Vol. 6, 1254—1278Paton
Vol. 2, 267—280Credits
Encoder (metadata)
Transcriber
Proofreader
Proofreader
Encoder
Encoder
Status
Document
Metadata
Correspondence
sent
| Person | Revd.Reverend Mr. George Innes | 
| Date | 15 Mar 1749 | 
| Place | Forres | 
| Place | Crieff | 
received
| Person | Robert Forbes | 
| Date | 29 Apr 1749 | 
acknowledgements
quote
As I wrote you some time ago (Paton V.2, 267).
compliments to
enclosed in
enclosures
quote
Meantime I send you two sheets of a narrative (Paton V.2, 268).
requests
quote
Let me know if you think by the inclos'd that the rest will be worth sending you (Paton V.2, 268).
remediation
in Forbes
Related Documents
Active:
                                
Journal taken from the Mouths
                        of
                        
                        of Laird of MackInnon, Mr Malcolm 
                            Mac-Leod, Lady Clanronald and Miss 
                                Flora Mac-Donald, by etc. (v01.0125.01): Mentions in footnote
Journal from the Retreat from Stirling 
                        to the Prince's Embarkation for France, being 
                        particular and exact, by Mr John Cameron, etc. (v01.0155.01): Mentions in footnote
Malcolm MacLeod's Journal; 
                     wherein likewise his own History 
                     and several very remarkable Particulars (v02.0228.01): Mentions in footnote
Journal of Donald MacLeod, &c. (v02.0266.01): Mentions in footnote
Copy of a Letter, said to be written by Lord George Murray, or one of his Friends, 1746 (v03.0429.01): Mentions in footnote
Colonel Ker of Gradyne his Account (v04.0648.01): Mentions in footnote
Copy of Captain Oneille's Journal taken from 
                     a Copy attested by his Name subscribed with 
                     his own Hand, with several critical Notes
                            upon the said Journal (v04.0670.01): Mentions in footnote
Macpherson of Strathmashie's Account of 
                            Clifton-battle, some Attacks in Athol, 
                            and of burning Cluny's House (v05.0890.01): Mentions in footnote
Copy of James Gib's Accompts Master-household to the Prince, being an excellent 
                     Journal, interspersed with several curious Notes and Observations (v05.0966.01): Mentions in footnote
Account how I came by Mr. Gib's Pocket-book 
                     of Accompts, and of several Conversations I had 
                            with him at different Times (v05.1009.01): Mentions in footnote
Captain Robert Stewart's account of the Skirmish at Keith, distinct & particular (v06.1138.01): Mentions in footnote
Narrative by him of the skirmish at Keith (v06.1138.02): Mentions in footnote
Paragraph of a Letter from the Reverend Mr
                George Innes, Forres, January 4th, 1748/9. (v06.1158.01): Mentions in footnote
Alexander Stewart's Memorial of his own Sufferings and Hardships, etc. January 30. 1749. (v06.1176.01): Mentions in footnote
Said Stewart's Account of the Design of seizing the 
                     Prince at Macintosh's House. (v06.1207.01): Mentions in footnote
Bellfinlay's Account of Countess of Finlater's
                     driving over the Field of Culloden immediately 
                     after the Action. April 1. 1749. (v06.1234.01): Mentions in footnote
Inscription designed for the Duke of Cumberland,
            in 
            Imitation of Dr Arbuthnot's upon Charteris. (v06.1279.01): Mentions in transcription
Copy of a Return to the foresaid Mr Innes,
            April 29. 1749 (v06.1280.01): Mentions in transcription
Passive:
                                
Malcolm MacLeod's Journal; 
                     wherein likewise his own History 
                     and several very remarkable Particulars (v02.0228.01): Mentioned in footnote
Journal of Donald MacLeod, &c. (v02.0266.01): Mentioned in footnote
Copy of a Letter, said to be written by Lord George Murray, or one of his Friends, 1746 (v03.0429.01): Mentioned in footnote
Colonel Ker of Gradyne his Account (v04.0648.01): Mentioned in footnote
Macpherson of Strathmashie's Account of 
                            Clifton-battle, some Attacks in Athol, 
                            and of burning Cluny's House (v05.0890.01): Mentioned in footnote
Account how I came by Mr. Gib's Pocket-book 
                     of Accompts, and of several Conversations I had 
                            with him at different Times (v05.1009.01): Mentioned in footnote
Inscription designed for the Duke of Cumberland,
            in 
            Imitation of Dr Arbuthnot's upon Charteris. (v06.1279.01): Mentioned in transcription
Copy of a Return to the foresaid Mr Innes,
            April 29. 1749 (v06.1280.01): Mentioned in transcription
Copy of a long Letter to the Reverend Mr James Hay in Inverness, containing 26 Queries. August 28. 1749. (v07.1425.01): Mentioned in footnote
Copy of Narratives from the Reverend Mr George Innes, Forres, February 27. 1750 (v07.1498.01): Mentioned in transcription
Transcription
┍
Copy of a Letter from the
			
RevdReverend Mr George Innes  in Forres, to me R:Robert F:Forbes
			R.Reverend D.Dear B.Brother
As I wrote you some time ago
			
I expected to have found a Bearer from
this Country whom I could have trusted
with a PacquetPacket for you; viz. your Acquain-
tance Miss Peggy Gedd who at that time
intended to have been soon in EdrEdinburgh. But
her Journey being so often put off, I
begin now to think that she will not
go before Whitsunday: And therefore
must defer sending you some of the
things you want, till some other cast up.
Mean timeMeantime, I send you two Sheets of
a Narrative, which when you have pe-
rus’dperused I shall be glad to have your Opi-
nion of; And would have sent you
more, but did not care to risquerisk the
whole at once, especially by a Bearer
that I am not well acquainted with.
Let me know if you think by the in-
clos’denclosed that the rest will be worth send-
ing you. I have been much troubled
these several Months past with sore
Eyes, which renders Writing very un-
easy to me; therefore beg you’ll re-
turn me these Scrapes1 when you can
as I have not a correct Copy of them.
      		
			I expected to have found a Bearer from
this Country whom I could have trusted
with a PacquetPacket for you; viz. your Acquain-
tance Miss Peggy Gedd who at that time
intended to have been soon in EdrEdinburgh. But
her Journey being so often put off, I
begin now to think that she will not
go before Whitsunday: And therefore
must defer sending you some of the
things you want, till some other cast up.
Mean timeMeantime, I send you two Sheets of
a Narrative, which when you have pe-
rus’dperused I shall be glad to have your Opi-
nion of; And would have sent you
more, but did not care to risquerisk the
whole at once, especially by a Bearer
that I am not well acquainted with.
Let me know if you think by the in-
clos’denclosed that the rest will be worth send-
ing you. I have been much troubled
these several Months past with sore
Eyes, which renders Writing very un-
easy to me; therefore beg you’ll re-
turn me these Scrapes1 when you can
as I have not a correct Copy of them.
There is a little Performance
			in
				1255
			(1255)
			
in Imitation of Dr Arbuthnot’s upon
Charteris said to be done in this Coun-
try about the time of the Battle of
Vall, at wcwhich time indeed I saw it,
which you may call for from Miss
Gedd’s Sister at EdrEdinburgh to whom she
is to send it. I wish you a happy
Easter &and ever am
			in Imitation of Dr Arbuthnot’s upon
Charteris said to be done in this Coun-
try about the time of the Battle of
Vall, at wcwhich time indeed I saw it,
which you may call for from Miss
Gedd’s Sister at EdrEdinburgh to whom she
is to send it. I wish you a happy
Easter &and ever am
R.Reverend D.Dear B.Brother
 15 March
			
1748/9
1748/9
Copy of the two Sheets of
			
a Narrative mentioned in
the preceedingpreceding Letter.
			a Narrative mentioned in
the preceedingpreceding Letter.
When the Prince’s Retreat from Stir-
ling came to be known at Inverness,
Lord Loudon &and the President made a
ShewShow as if they intended to maintain
themselves in that important Place.
The Laird of McLeod, &and Monroe of
Culcairn had taken up their Quar-
ters at Forres, from the time of
their Defeat at Inverury, &and had pret-
ty well recruited their respective
Corps. 200 of Sir Alexander McDo-
nald’s Men had likewise join’djoined them;
but upon the news of the Prince’s
March, they were all call’dcalled in to In-verness,1256(1256)verness, where with the Grants, McKenzies,
GunnsGunn's, Loudon’s Regiment &and others, they
made up in all a Body of about 2000
Men. The D.Duke of Cumberland did cer-
tainly expect, that there wou’dwould have
been sufficient to have done the Bu-
siness in the North. For a Letter from
him was intercepted at Huntly, tel-
ling Loudon that he had dispers’ddispersed
the Rebels, &and that it was his positive
Orders to make head agtagainst them, in
case they shou’dshould attempt any thinganything
more. But Loudon &and the President
knew better how the Case Stood: They
did not trust their own Men, &and had
sure enough Intelligence that the
Prince’s Army was not so much dis-
pers'ddispersed as was given out. Therefore
they caus’dcaused throw up some sham In-
trenchmentsEntrenchments on one Side of the Town,
but their main Design seems to have
been the surprizingsurprising of the Prince’s✝ Per-
son; which would not only have ruin’druined
his Cause, but wou’dwould likewise have en-
titled them to the £30,000. For this pur-
pose, when he came toX McKintosh’s house
within a few Miles of them, the whole
Posseφ march’dmarched out of Inverness very se-
cretly in the Night: And had it not been
				
been for the Care of his Female
Friends, ‘tisit is very probable they might
have succeeded in their Attempt. Some
of these at Inverness2 dispatch’ddispatched a
Messenger to inform him of his Dan-
ger: And at the same time, his
Land-Lady, without knowing any thinganything
of the Design, had order’dordered one Fraser
a Blacksmith, a trusty stout Fellow,
who liv’dlived hard by, &and knew all the Roads,
to keep a sharp look-out the whole
Night, as there were but a very few
of the Prince’s People with him at
her House. Accordingly it happen’dhappened
that Fraser discover’ddiscovered the Enemy;
upon whom he immediately fir’dfired his
Piece, &and had the Presence of Mind
to cry out; as if he had a party
near, to advance, for the Dogs were
coming up: Which so allarm’dalarmed ^them, that
immediately they turn’dturned tail, &and made
the best of their Way to Inverness.
			ling came to be known at Inverness,
Lord Loudon &and the President made a
ShewShow as if they intended to maintain
themselves in that important Place.
The Laird of McLeod, &and Monroe of
Culcairn had taken up their Quar-
ters at Forres, from the time of
their Defeat at Inverury, &and had pret-
ty well recruited their respective
Corps. 200 of Sir Alexander McDo-
nald’s Men had likewise join’djoined them;
but upon the news of the Prince’s
March, they were all call’dcalled in to In-verness,1256(1256)verness, where with the Grants, McKenzies,
GunnsGunn's, Loudon’s Regiment &and others, they
made up in all a Body of about 2000
Men. The D.Duke of Cumberland did cer-
tainly expect, that there wou’dwould have
been sufficient to have done the Bu-
siness in the North. For a Letter from
him was intercepted at Huntly, tel-
ling Loudon that he had dispers’ddispersed
the Rebels, &and that it was his positive
Orders to make head agtagainst them, in
case they shou’dshould attempt any thinganything
more. But Loudon &and the President
knew better how the Case Stood: They
did not trust their own Men, &and had
sure enough Intelligence that the
Prince’s Army was not so much dis-
pers'ddispersed as was given out. Therefore
they caus’dcaused throw up some sham In-
trenchmentsEntrenchments on one Side of the Town,
but their main Design seems to have
been the surprizingsurprising of the Prince’s✝ Per-
son; which would not only have ruin’druined
his Cause, but wou’dwould likewise have en-
titled them to the £30,000. For this pur-
pose, when he came toX McKintosh’s house
within a few Miles of them, the whole
Posseφ march’dmarched out of Inverness very se-
cretly in the Night: And had it not been
✝Xφ  
				
				1257
			(1257)
			Vol:Volume 2, p:page 258, &cetc. The exact Agreement in yethe several
			
Accounts of this Affair by Persons, qowho could not compare Notes wtwith
one anoyranother is truly remarkable. Vol:Volume 4. p:page 648, &cetc. Vol:Volume 5. P:Page 989, &cetc.
Vol:Volume 6. pag:page 1207
		Accounts of this Affair by Persons, qowho could not compare Notes wtwith
one anoyranother is truly remarkable. Vol:Volume 4. p:page 648, &cetc. Vol:Volume 5. P:Page 989, &cetc.
Vol:Volume 6. pag:page 1207
Robert Forbes, A:M:
been for the Care of his Female
Friends, ‘tisit is very probable they might
have succeeded in their Attempt. Some
of these at Inverness2 dispatch’ddispatched a
Messenger to inform him of his Dan-
ger: And at the same time, his
Land-Lady, without knowing any thinganything
of the Design, had order’dordered one Fraser
a Blacksmith, a trusty stout Fellow,
who liv’dlived hard by, &and knew all the Roads,
to keep a sharp look-out the whole
Night, as there were but a very few
of the Prince’s People with him at
her House. Accordingly it happen’dhappened
that Fraser discover’ddiscovered the Enemy;
upon whom he immediately fir’dfired his
Piece, &and had the Presence of Mind
to cry out; as if he had a party
near, to advance, for the Dogs were
coming up: Which so allarm’dalarmed ^them, that
immediately they turn’dturned tail, &and made
the best of their Way to Inverness.
But tho’though they miss’dmissed catching the
			
Prince’s Person, they hurt his Health
very much by this Attempt. For, upon
getting the AllarmAlarm, he run hastily
out of Bed to call up his Men, &and,
as it was a keen frost, contracted
thereby such a Cold, as stuck to him
very long, &and I may ev’neven say, endanger’dendangered his 1258 (1258)
his Life; Which was one great Reason
of his staying so much at Inverness af-
terwards, to the great Detriment of
his Affairs in other Places. However
he advanced next Day, &and no sooner
came in Sight of Inverness, than✝ Lou-
don &and his Party retreated in a great
Hurry, by the ferry of Kessack, to Ross,
&and afterwards to Sutherland: And in
a few Days after, Major Grant sur-
render’dsurrendered the Castle, which was of no
considerable Strength, &and was garri-
son’dgarrisoned only by one Company of regu-
lar Troops, &and 2 or 3 Companies of the
above-mention’dmentioned Militia,3 who had
neither Skill nor Inclination to de-
fend the place. Yet the GovernourGovernor
was afterwards tried by a Court-Marti-
al, &and discharg’ddischarged the Service, one of the
Officers who were Evidences agtagainst him,
having sworn what was not only
false but impossible in fact; viz.
that he saw the Highlanders drawn
up at the Market-Cross, &and wou’dwould not
allow to fire on them: Whereas the
whole Streets, except a little of the
Kirk-Street, were entirely cover’dcovered, &and
not a Man upon them could be seen
from the Fort. Mean timeMeantime LdLord George
Murray came up with the other Divi-
sion
			
				
				1259(1259)sion of the Army by the Way of AbdAberdeen:
			
And a Detachment was immediately
sent off to besiege Fort-Augustus,
which they soon took, &and afterwards
laid Siege to Fort-William, Lochiel
&and all the Highlanders being very an-
xious to have the Country clear’dcleared
of Garrisons, which would have en-
gag’dengaged the ClannsClans in those Parts,
young &and old, to turn out. But they
were not provided with the Neces-
saries proper for attacking so strong
a Place, &and so were oblig’dobliged to raise
the Siege with the Loss of several
brave Men. At the same time, the
D:DukeX of Perth went in Pursuit of Lord
Loudon &and the President, &and having got
Boats from the Murray-Side, very
narrowly miss’dmissed surprizingsurprising them all
at Dornoch where Major McKenzie
&and some others were taken; But Lou-
don, the President, McLeod, &and Cul-
cairn got off, &and went most of them
to the Isle of Skie, where they
remained till after the Battle of
Culloden. LdLord George Murray likewise
march’dmarched to Athole; but I am not well
informed of the ✝particulars of that Ex-
pedition. ‘TisIt is said that he urg’durged the
Prince very much to send him a Rein-forcement
			
				
			
		
				
				1260(1260)
forcement of 1000 Highlanders, promis-
ing, on that Condition, to give a good
Account of the Hessians. But that
Proposal was over-rul’doverruled, it seems, by
those at Inverness, who were quite
bent upon reducing all in the North,
in order to bring out the ClannsClans, &and
leave no Enemy behind them.
About this time some of Fitz-James’s
Dragoons landed at AbdAberdeen, &and ‘twasit was said
a good many more were then upon
the Coast, but did not know where
to put in, as they expected to have
found the Prince in the South of
Scotland. And, within a few Days
thereafter, the D:Duke of Cumberland ar-
riv’darrived there wtwith his Army, upon which
the Parties of the Highland Army in
that Country retreated first to Huntly,
&and afterwards, upon the coming up of
some Regiments from AbdAberdeen, to Focha-
bers. A small Detachment of King-
ston’s light Horse &and of the Camp-
bells, advanc’dadvanced as far as Keith; where
they were✝ surpriz’dsurprised in the Night, some
of them kill’dkilled, &and the rest taken priso-
ners; most of whom were sent to
France aboard a small Vessel from
Findhorn. Mean timeMeantime, Money grew
very scarce in the Highland Army, which
			
selves up &and down the Country, to
raise the Levy-money, Cess, &and Excise,
&and to get in Grain &and Meal for
their Subsistence. The Hazzard
Sloop wcwhich had been sent to France,
was✝ unluckily forc’dforced ^ashore by a Man of
Warashore upon LdLord Rhea’s Country,
			
where a few Gentlemen landed, wtwith
a considerable Sum of Money,
most people say 10000 Pounds;
All which, together with those that
had the Charge of it, was imme-
diately taken by a Posse of the
McKays sent out by LdLord Rhea for
that Purpose. The Earl of Cro-
marty &and his Son were sent to Caith-
ness to raise what Money &and Friends
cou’dcould be got there; But they never
return’dreturned, being takenX at Dunrobin, in
their Way back to Inverness, much about
the time of the Battle of Culloden.
And here I cannot but observe, that
LdLord Cromarty was the only Person in
the Highland Army I ever heard
of who caus’dcaused burn a Gentleman’s
House upon any Pretence whatso-
ever. It belong’dbelonged to Gordon of Carrol,
Factor to the Earl of Sutherland, who having
			 
			
			
			
				1262
			(1262)
			having promis’dpromised to pay the Levy-Money
			
&cetc agtagainst a certain Day, instead of that
went off in a Boat to AbdAberdeen. Whereupon
Lord Cromarty gave Orders to burn his
house, which was of no great Value;
And ev’ry thingeverything in it was carefully
taken out &and put into the Office-hous-
es for the Owner’s Behoof. However
this Procedure was very much con-
demn’dcondemned at Inverness, &and I believe
in the only Instance of that Kind can
be given.
 Prince’s Person, they hurt his Health
very much by this Attempt. For, upon
getting the AllarmAlarm, he run hastily
out of Bed to call up his Men, &and,
as it was a keen frost, contracted
thereby such a Cold, as stuck to him
very long, &and I may ev’neven say, endanger’dendangered his 1258 (1258)
his Life; Which was one great Reason
of his staying so much at Inverness af-
terwards, to the great Detriment of
his Affairs in other Places. However
he advanced next Day, &and no sooner
came in Sight of Inverness, than✝ Lou-
don &and his Party retreated in a great
Hurry, by the ferry of Kessack, to Ross,
&and afterwards to Sutherland: And in
a few Days after, Major Grant sur-
render’dsurrendered the Castle, which was of no
considerable Strength, &and was garri-
son’dgarrisoned only by one Company of regu-
lar Troops, &and 2 or 3 Companies of the
above-mention’dmentioned Militia,3 who had
neither Skill nor Inclination to de-
fend the place. Yet the GovernourGovernor
was afterwards tried by a Court-Marti-
al, &and discharg’ddischarged the Service, one of the
Officers who were Evidences agtagainst him,
having sworn what was not only
false but impossible in fact; viz.
that he saw the Highlanders drawn
up at the Market-Cross, &and wou’dwould not
allow to fire on them: Whereas the
whole Streets, except a little of the
Kirk-Street, were entirely cover’dcovered, &and
not a Man upon them could be seen
from the Fort. Mean timeMeantime LdLord George
Murray came up with the other Divi-
sion
And a Detachment was immediately
sent off to besiege Fort-Augustus,
which they soon took, &and afterwards
laid Siege to Fort-William, Lochiel
&and all the Highlanders being very an-
xious to have the Country clear’dcleared
of Garrisons, which would have en-
gag’dengaged the ClannsClans in those Parts,
young &and old, to turn out. But they
were not provided with the Neces-
saries proper for attacking so strong
a Place, &and so were oblig’dobliged to raise
the Siege with the Loss of several
brave Men. At the same time, the
D:DukeX of Perth went in Pursuit of Lord
Loudon &and the President, &and having got
Boats from the Murray-Side, very
narrowly miss’dmissed surprizingsurprising them all
at Dornoch where Major McKenzie
&and some others were taken; But Lou-
don, the President, McLeod, &and Cul-
cairn got off, &and went most of them
to the Isle of Skie, where they
remained till after the Battle of
Culloden. LdLord George Murray likewise
march’dmarched to Athole; but I am not well
informed of the ✝particulars of that Ex-
pedition. ‘TisIt is said that he urg’durged the
Prince very much to send him a Rein-forcement
forcement of 1000 Highlanders, promis-
ing, on that Condition, to give a good
Account of the Hessians. But that
Proposal was over-rul’doverruled, it seems, by
those at Inverness, who were quite
bent upon reducing all in the North,
in order to bring out the ClannsClans, &and
leave no Enemy behind them.
About this time some of Fitz-James’s
Dragoons landed at AbdAberdeen, &and ‘twasit was said
a good many more were then upon
the Coast, but did not know where
to put in, as they expected to have
found the Prince in the South of
Scotland. And, within a few Days
thereafter, the D:Duke of Cumberland ar-
riv’darrived there wtwith his Army, upon which
the Parties of the Highland Army in
that Country retreated first to Huntly,
&and afterwards, upon the coming up of
some Regiments from AbdAberdeen, to Focha-
bers. A small Detachment of King-
ston’s light Horse &and of the Camp-
bells, advanc’dadvanced as far as Keith; where
they were✝ surpriz’dsurprised in the Night, some
of them kill’dkilled, &and the rest taken priso-
ners; most of whom were sent to
France aboard a small Vessel from
Findhorn. Mean timeMeantime, Money grew
very scarce in the Highland Army, which
✝ 
			
				
			1261
			(1261)
			which oblig’dobliged them to disperse them-Robert Forbes, A:M:
selves up &and down the Country, to
raise the Levy-money, Cess, &and Excise,
&and to get in Grain &and Meal for
their Subsistence. The Hazzard
Sloop wcwhich had been sent to France,
was✝ unluckily forc’dforced ^ashore by a Man of
War
where a few Gentlemen landed, wtwith
a considerable Sum of Money,
most people say 10000 Pounds;
All which, together with those that
had the Charge of it, was imme-
diately taken by a Posse of the
McKays sent out by LdLord Rhea for
that Purpose. The Earl of Cro-
marty &and his Son were sent to Caith-
ness to raise what Money &and Friends
cou’dcould be got there; But they never
return’dreturned, being takenX at Dunrobin, in
their Way back to Inverness, much about
the time of the Battle of Culloden.
And here I cannot but observe, that
LdLord Cromarty was the only Person in
the Highland Army I ever heard
of who caus’dcaused burn a Gentleman’s
House upon any Pretence whatso-
ever. It belong’dbelonged to Gordon of Carrol,
Factor to the Earl of Sutherland, who having
&cetc agtagainst a certain Day, instead of that
went off in a Boat to AbdAberdeen. Whereupon
Lord Cromarty gave Orders to burn his
house, which was of no great Value;
And ev’ry thingeverything in it was carefully
taken out &and put into the Office-hous-
es for the Owner’s Behoof. However
this Procedure was very much con-
demn’dcondemned at Inverness, &and I believe
in the only Instance of that Kind can
be given.
Since writing this I am inform’dinformed that
			
Carrol lays the whole Blame of his
house being burntburned upon Barrisdale.
Carrol lays the whole Blame of his
house being burntburned upon Barrisdale.
The Earl of Findlater’s Factor being
			
likewise order’dordered to pay his Proportion of
the Levy-Money, there came a very
arrogant Epistle from the Earl him-
self, then at AbdAberdeen, directed either to
his Factor, or to the Presbyterian MinrMinister
at Cullen (I don’t well remember
which) insulting the whole highland
Army, &and particularly Lord John Drum-
mond, who then commanded the Forces
at Spey, &and forbidding to pay the Levy-
money, or any thinganything else. This Letter
being publish’dpublished did so irritate Major
Glasgow, that he went with a Party &and
pillag’dpillaged a good many Rooms of Lord
Findlater’s House. ‘TwasIt was at first given
out, that this was done by Lord John
Drummond’s Orders, by Way of Repri-
sal for the innumerable Things of that kind 1263 (1263) kind that had been &and were daily
done by the D:Duke of Cumberland’s Or-
ders, &and to try if the finding their own
friends treated in the same Way,
wou’dwould put a Stop to such Practices for
the time to come. But a Gentleman
of Honour assures me, that he heard
LdLord John refuse the haveinghaving given
any such Orders, &and Glasgow take the
whole of it upon himself.
				
			likewise order’dordered to pay his Proportion of
the Levy-Money, there came a very
arrogant Epistle from the Earl him-
self, then at AbdAberdeen, directed either to
his Factor, or to the Presbyterian MinrMinister
at Cullen (I don’t well remember
which) insulting the whole highland
Army, &and particularly Lord John Drum-
mond, who then commanded the Forces
at Spey, &and forbidding to pay the Levy-
money, or any thinganything else. This Letter
being publish’dpublished did so irritate Major
Glasgow, that he went with a Party &and
pillag’dpillaged a good many Rooms of Lord
Findlater’s House. ‘TwasIt was at first given
out, that this was done by Lord John
Drummond’s Orders, by Way of Repri-
sal for the innumerable Things of that kind 1263 (1263) kind that had been &and were daily
done by the D:Duke of Cumberland’s Or-
ders, &and to try if the finding their own
friends treated in the same Way,
wou’dwould put a Stop to such Practices for
the time to come. But a Gentleman
of Honour assures me, that he heard
LdLord John refuse the haveinghaving given
any such Orders, &and Glasgow take the
whole of it upon himself.
Soon after this the D:Duke of Cumber-
land began his March from AbdAberdeen;
And was actually at Banff ’ere
any sure Intelligence was got of
his Motions. For he had stay’dstayed so long
at AbdAberdeen; &and so many false Reports of
his having march’dmarched had been rais’draised
formerly, that at last his Enemies
turn’dturned quite secure. As a Prelude
to what was to happen afterwards, he
caus’dcaused hang a poor innocent Man at
Banff, &and another atBeenny within
			
a Mile of the former, on Pretence of
their being Spies; tho’though such as knew
them affirm they had scarce Wit e-
nough to do their own Country-Busi-
ness, far less to play the Spy. There like-
wise the Army destroyed a fine ChappelChapel,
belonging to the Episcopal Congrega-
tion, cutting down the Roof, burning
the Seats, Books, Pulpit &and Altar &and
breaking the Organto^in Pieces. And this
			was
				
				1264
			(1264)
			
was their constant Practice all the
Way they march’dmarched; with this Difference,
that in Country-Places they stay’dstayed not
to take any thinganything out, but burntburned Hous-
es, Bibles, Prayer-Books &and all, as
at New-Durn, Clyn-hill,✝ Keam of Duf-
fus &and many others. And many both
Officers &and Soldiers have since de-
clared, that all this was done at
the Instigation of the Presbyterians,
&and was indeed a genuine new-Edi-
tion of their Father Knox’s first
Reformation. The Houses of a great
manyX Gentlemen that were with the
Prince were likewise pillag’dpillaged with the
greatest Rigour: And indeed, facts of
this kind were so many &and notorious,
that it were quite superfluous to
condescend on particular Instances.
From Banff the D.Duke marched to Cullen,
where, I’m assur’dassured, he was lodg’dlodged by the
worthyφ Countess in the Room of the
House that had suffer’dsuffered most, to shewshow
their Distress, &and plead Pity! And next
Day he cross’dcrossed the River Spey with-
out the least Opposition, to the great
Amazement of ev’ry Bodyeverybody who knew
how deep &and rapid that River was:
For tho’though it was fordable ev’neven by the
foot, yet ‘tisit is certain, a very little
Opposition must have put his Army
into great Confusion.
			Let
			land began his March from AbdAberdeen;
And was actually at Banff ’ere
any sure Intelligence was got of
his Motions. For he had stay’dstayed so long
at AbdAberdeen; &and so many false Reports of
his having march’dmarched had been rais’draised
formerly, that at last his Enemies
turn’dturned quite secure. As a Prelude
to what was to happen afterwards, he
caus’dcaused hang a poor innocent Man at
Banff, &and another at
Boindy +
a Mile of the former, on Pretence of
their being Spies; tho’though such as knew
them affirm they had scarce Wit e-
nough to do their own Country-Busi-
ness, far less to play the Spy. There like-
wise the Army destroyed a fine ChappelChapel,
belonging to the Episcopal Congrega-
tion, cutting down the Roof, burning
the Seats, Books, Pulpit &and Altar &and
breaking the Organ
was their constant Practice all the
Way they march’dmarched; with this Difference,
that in Country-Places they stay’dstayed not
to take any thinganything out, but burntburned Hous-
es, Bibles, Prayer-Books &and all, as
at New-Durn, Clyn-hill,✝ Keam of Duf-
fus &and many others. And many both
Officers &and Soldiers have since de-
clared, that all this was done at
the Instigation of the Presbyterians,
&and was indeed a genuine new-Edi-
tion of their Father Knox’s first
Reformation. The Houses of a great
manyX Gentlemen that were with the
Prince were likewise pillag’dpillaged with the
greatest Rigour: And indeed, facts of
this kind were so many &and notorious,
that it were quite superfluous to
condescend on particular Instances.
From Banff the D.Duke marched to Cullen,
where, I’m assur’dassured, he was lodg’dlodged by the
worthyφ Countess in the Room of the
House that had suffer’dsuffered most, to shewshow
their Distress, &and plead Pity! And next
Day he cross’dcrossed the River Spey with-
out the least Opposition, to the great
Amazement of ev’ry Bodyeverybody who knew
how deep &and rapid that River was:
For tho’though it was fordable ev’neven by the
foot, yet ‘tisit is certain, a very little
Opposition must have put his Army
into great Confusion.
Let us therefore take a View of
			
the other Army, that we may the bet-
ter judge whence this Misconduct
happen’dhappened. And certain it is, that the
unfortunate Prince labour’dlaboured under
innumerable Difficulties at that time;
many of wcwhich were alone sufficient to
have ruin’druined his Affairs: for, not to
mention the private DissentionsDissensions that
had unhappilyarisen among some
			
of the great Folks about him; he
was in great✝ Want both of Money
&and Intelligence. Several Aberdeen-
Shire-Gentlemen who were con-
fident that it was impossible for
the Duke to move thro’through their Coun-
try without their being inform’dinformed of
it, were nevertheless within an Ace
of being surpriz’dsurprised drinking in a Gen-
tleman’s House in the Enzie by the
Enemie’sEnemy’s advanc’dadvanced Guard, which
was within a few Miles of them
‘erewhere they had the least Notice of
what was doing. This want of Intel-
ligence, was of very bad Conse-
quence; for they who guarded the
Pass ^of Spey under the Command of Duke
of Perth &and his Brother, were oblig’dobliged
to march off in such a hurry that it
both frighten’dfrightened &and fatigu’dfatigued the Men very much
			
			
				1266
			(1266)
			much. And the Athole Brigade, wtwith
			
Roy-Stuart’s Regiment who were
posted farther up the River towards
the Grant’s Country, had scarce time
enough to get clear off. There was
indeed a Design of bringing the whole
highland Army towards Spey, in order
either to attack that Body of the Ene-
my which lay at Huntly, or to dispute
the Passage of the River with them,
shou’dshould their whole Army advance.
And a part of the Frasers were ac-
tually on their March for that pur-
pose. But the D.Duke of Cumberland
had so good Intelligence from his
Friends in Murray, that, before the
scatter’dscattered parties of the Clannsclans cou'dcould
be got together, he made a quick
March, pass’dpassed the Spey, as I have
already told, on the Saturday, march’dmarched
to Alves on the Sunday, &and from that
to Nairn on the Monday, where he
rested Tuesday the 15th. There he gave
an uncommon Proof of his merciful
Disposition; for a poorMan fellow hav-
ing been hang’dhanged up as a Spy, upon As-
surances of his Innocency &and at the Solici-
tation of the✝ PresbytPresbyterian MinrMinister he graciously
order’dordered him to be cut down, time enough to save
			
			the other Army, that we may the bet-
ter judge whence this Misconduct
happen’dhappened. And certain it is, that the
unfortunate Prince labour’dlaboured under
innumerable Difficulties at that time;
many of wcwhich were alone sufficient to
have ruin’druined his Affairs: for, not to
mention the private DissentionsDissensions that
had unhappily
of the great Folks about him; he
was in great✝ Want both of Money
&and Intelligence. Several Aberdeen-
Shire-Gentlemen who were con-
fident that it was impossible for
the Duke to move thro’through their Coun-
try without their being inform’dinformed of
it, were nevertheless within an Ace
of being surpriz’dsurprised drinking in a Gen-
tleman’s House in the Enzie by the
Enemie’sEnemy’s advanc’dadvanced Guard, which
was within a few Miles of them
‘erewhere they had the least Notice of
what was doing. This want of Intel-
ligence, was of very bad Conse-
quence; for they who guarded the
Pass ^of Spey under the Command of Duke
of Perth &and his Brother, were oblig’dobliged
to march off in such a hurry that it
both frighten’dfrightened &and fatigu’dfatigued the Men very much
Roy-Stuart’s Regiment who were
posted farther up the River towards
the Grant’s Country, had scarce time
enough to get clear off. There was
indeed a Design of bringing the whole
highland Army towards Spey, in order
either to attack that Body of the Ene-
my which lay at Huntly, or to dispute
the Passage of the River with them,
shou’dshould their whole Army advance.
And a part of the Frasers were ac-
tually on their March for that pur-
pose. But the D.Duke of Cumberland
had so good Intelligence from his
Friends in Murray, that, before the
scatter’dscattered parties of the Clannsclans cou'dcould
be got together, he made a quick
March, pass’dpassed the Spey, as I have
already told, on the Saturday, march’dmarched
to Alves on the Sunday, &and from that
to Nairn on the Monday, where he
rested Tuesday the 15th. There he gave
an uncommon Proof of his merciful
Disposition; for a poor
ing been hang’dhanged up as a Spy, upon As-
surances of his Innocency &and at the Solici-
tation of the✝ PresbytPresbyterian MinrMinister he graciously
order’dordered him to be cut down, time enough to save
✝ 
				
				1267
			(1267)
			save his Life.Mr Rose, who (when in Edinburgh at the Gene-
ral Assembly in 1748) owned the Truth of this
Fact, in all it’sits Parts, to several Persons, who
asked him about it.
ral Assembly in 1748) owned the Truth of this
Fact, in all it’sits Parts, to several Persons, who
asked him about it.
Robert Forbes, A:M:
Mean timeMeantime, those under the Duke
			
of Perth being join’djoined by the other Par-
ties who were canton’dcantoned in Moray
Made a considerable Body at Nairn
upon Monday, &and stay’dstayed there till
the Duke’s Army came pretty near.
But wanting the ClannsClans, in whom
their chief Confidence lay, they
continue their March in good Order
towards the House of Culloden,
having Fitz-Jame’sJames’ Horse, the Guards,
&and the Hussars covering their Rear, &and
skirmishing sometimes with the Camp-
bells, Light-Horse &and Dragoons, who
had been sent to harass them.
			of Perth being join’djoined by the other Par-
ties who were canton’dcantoned in Moray
Made a considerable Body at Nairn
upon Monday, &and stay’dstayed there till
the Duke’s Army came pretty near.
But wanting the ClannsClans, in whom
their chief Confidence lay, they
continue their March in good Order
towards the House of Culloden,
having Fitz-Jame’sJames’ Horse, the Guards,
&and the Hussars covering their Rear, &and
skirmishing sometimes with the Camp-
bells, Light-Horse &and Dragoons, who
had been sent to harass them.
Notwithstanding the many Expresses
			
that had been sent to hasten their
joining the Prince at Inverness, the
ClannsClans were at that Time so scat-
ter’dscattered, that it was Monday ✝night the
14th ‘ere the Camerons arriv’darrived at
the Camp. And of them came only
about half the Number that had ap-
pear’dappeared at Falkirk, it being impossi-
ble to get such of them as liv’dlived in
the Neighbourhood of Fort-William
to turn out, till that Place shou’dshould be
reduc’dreduced. On Tuesday Keppoch’s Mack-
donalds came up as much reduc’dreduced in
Proportion, as the former. Clan-rannald
had but a mere handful of his People.
Clunie* was still in Badenoch with about 800
			
			
			
			
				1268
			(1268)
			800 Men. The McKenzies were with
			
Lord Cromarty in Sutherland; as were
the McGreggors, the McKinnons, &and a Party
of the McDonalds with Barrisdale;
And the half of the Frazers were only
on their March with their young Chief,
at the very time of their Engagement.
So that ‘tisit is certain the Prince wanted
upwards of 2000 of his very best High-
landers ev’neven upon Tuesday evening
when his Army was at the best. How-
ever, upon Monday Night, he order’dordered
them to form, &and reston their Arms in
			
&and about Culloden-Parks, while the
Artillery &and Ammunition was brought carried
out of Inverness. Upon Tuesday Mor-
ning, the whole Army was drawn
up to Culloden Muir, &and there form’dformed
in Order of Battle, consisting of a
Front &and second Lines, with a small
Reserve. All the Men seem’dseemed to be
in great Spirits expecting the Ene-
my ev’ryevery Moment. The Prince (who
was dress’ddressed in a Tartan Jacket &and Buff
Vest) rode with his AidAide-de-Camps
from right to left, &and address’daddressed each
different Corps with a chearfulcheerful Smile
&and Salute, while they return’dreturned with
loud Huzzas, especially when any
of the Scouts came in with ^an AllarmAlarm/;
And the AllarmAlarm was given several times, 1269 (1269)
times, on purpose to animate them.
Thus pastpassed the Tuesday, till towards
the Evening, when a general Coun-
cil of War was call’dcalled, in which,
after Xsome Disputes, it was re-
solv’dresolved to march all Night &and attack
the Enemy in their Camp at Nairn,
wcwhich was ^at about✝ ten Miles Distance.
It was agreed upon, that the Army
shou’dshould be divided into two Columns;
the one consisting of the ClannsClans,
commanded by Lord George Murray,
was to advance about a quarter
of a Mile before the other, in order
to surround φ Town of Nairn, &and
form their Attack on the East &and
North Sides of the Duke’s Camp:
Whilst the other Column, consist-
ing of the French &and Low-land Re-
giments, commanded by the Duke
of Perth, was to attack them upon
the South &and West Sides, all at one
time. The Night was dark &and some-
what foggy, which no doubt gave
great Numbers an Opportunity to
desert: And the Ground through
which they march’dmarched was very rough
&and unev’nuneven. However they went on,
till the first Column[]me was almost at
			[a]
			
			
			
		
			
				1270
			(1270)
			a Place call’dcalled Killdrummie within two
			
Miles of the Duke’s Camp, when all
of a sudden they were order’dordered to
wheel about &and return to Culloden.
Who, ✝or what it was that occasion’doccasioned
this unlucky Retreat, I shall not
pretend with any Certainty to deter-
mine. But common Report, &and ev’neven
the best Authority I have yet met
with fixes it upon XLord George
Murray. Some alledgeallege, that the Co-
lumn he commanded had gone a
little out of the Way; &and that being
afraid he shou’dshould not be able to reach
the Enemy before Day-light, he
advis’dadvised with the Gentlemen who com-
manded under him, &and gave it as
his Opinion that they shou’dshould retreat
to which ‘tisit is said they unanimously
agreed. ‘TisIt is likewise said that they
heard the Dragoons at Auldearn, two
Miles east-ward of Nairn beating
their Drums for Saddles &and Bridles,
which they took to be an Allarmalarm in
the Duke’s Camp. Others give out
that Lochiel was the first who pro-
pos’dproposed their marching back, on account
of the great Desertion he found among
his
				
			
			
his Men. But, be that as it will,
certain it is the Prince was ✝not con-
sulted; &and tho’though Master of his Tem-
per beyond Thousands, ‘tisit is impossi-
ble to express the Concern he was in
upon meeting the Duke of Perth’s
Regiment in their Way back. Some
			
positively say that he cry’dcried out, “I
“am betray’dbetrayed; What need I give Or-
“ders, when my Orders are disobey’ddisobeyed?
He call’dcalled for the Duke of Perth, who
came soon up to him &and inform’dinformed him
that the other Column had retreat-
ed; &and that Lord George had sent
orders to him, viz the Duke of Perth,
to return to Culloden. He was ve-
ry keen for sending Orders to Lord
George to return, but being told,
that Lord George was already so
far on his Way back that it wou’dwould
be impossible to bring up the Army
time enough to execute the intend-
ed plan, he said with an audible
Voice “‘TisIt is no Matter then; We shall
meet them &and behave like brave
Fellows. So back they march’dmarched, &and
arriv’darrived at Culloden about sev’nseven o’
Clock in the Morning. The fatigue
of this night's march join’djoined to the want of
			
				
			
				1272
			(1272)
			of Sleep for several Nights before, &and
			
the want of food, occasion’doccasioned a prodigious
murmuring among the private Men, ma-
ny of them exclaiming bitterly ev’neven in the
Prince’s hearing, which affected him ve-
ry much. Many of them fell asleep in
the Parks of Culloden &and other Places
near the Road &and never waken’dwakened till
they found the Enemy cutting their
Throats. Great numbers of them went
to Inverness &and other adjacent Places to
look for some Refreshment: So that
when certain Intelligence was brought
of the Enemy’s being hard at hand,
I’m assur’dassured there were not above a
thousand Men ready to appear on the
Field of Battle: And this oblig’dobliged them
to draw up about a ✝quarter of a Mile
farther back than they had done the
Day before, &and on a much less conve-
nient Spot of Ground. Such as were
at a Distance acted as their different
Inclinations led them; many of them,
no doubt endeavour’dendeavoured to provide for
their Safety by slipping off as fast
as they cou’dcould, whilst the rest hurried
to the field of Battle. About twelve o’
Clock the Lines were brought to some
confus’dconfused form. On the right of the front-
Line, were the Athole Brigade, Came-
rons &and Stuarts, commanded by Lord George
Murray
				
			
				1273
			(1273)
			Murray. In the Centre were the Mc-
Kintoshes, Farquharsons, McLeans, Mc-
Laughlans, &and Chisholms, commanded
by Lord John Drummond. And on the
left, were the Frasers &and McDonalds
of Keppoch &and Clan-rannald comman-
ded by the Duke of Perth. The second
Line, commanded by Roy Stuart, was
made up of Lowlanders, French,
Perth’s &and Glenbucket’s Regiments;
And the Reserve of Ogilvie’s. The
Right Wing was flank’dflanked by the Life
Guards, &and the Left by the Hussars,
which except 40 or 50 ^French Dragoons
ill-mounted, was all the High-
land Cavalry. But quite different
was their Appearance this Day, from
what it had been the Day before.
The Men were nodding with Sleep
in their Ranks, &and at least 1500 ^fewer in
Number. Ev’nEven the Prince himself, in
spite of all his Endeavours to the
contrary, was not able to conceal
that Damp which his last night’s
Disappointment had cast upon his
Spirits. And it is said, that he strong-
ly suspected his Designs had miscar-
ried thro’through Treachery. — On the other
hand, the Duke’s Army posted them-
selves on an advantagiousadvantageous ground, making 1274 (1274) making three Lines, cover’dcovered with Cannon
in the front, &and Dragoons on the right &and
left. They had likewise a Reserve of
Dragoons, &and some of these with the
Campbells had taken Possession of
a Park upon the High-lander’sHigh-landers’ Right,
in order to flank them either when
they shou’dshould advance or retreat. Some
of Stoniewood’s Regiment assert, that
Colonel Baggot had advis’dadvised to post
them along the outside of that Park-
dyke, which probably wou’dwould have pre-
vented a good deal of Mischief
these Campbells &and Dragoons afterwards
did; but✝ that Lord George Murray wou’dwould
not hear of it — Both Armies being now
within Cannon-shot of one another
the Highlanders took off their Bonnets,
&and gave a great Shout, which the Ene-
my answered with a huzza. Then
the Prince’s Cannon fir’dfired thrice from
Right to Left before the Duke’s, but
did little or no Execution, only the
Dragoons on the Left were observ’dobserved to
reel a little. Immediately after that
the Duke’s Cannon began, &and fir’dfired with-
out Intermission the whole time of
the Action: And tho’though many of the
Balls went quite over the Highland
Lines, yet there’s no doubt but such a long
				
				
			1275
			(1275)
			long &and uninterrupted fire kill’dkilled a
			
good many, especially after the Can-
non were loaded with Grape-shot
which was done upon the highlanders
advancing nearer. Matters looking
thus but very gloomy, the Prince
call’dcalled a short general Council
of War, in which some propos’dproposed to
retreat a little to the Hills, till
Clunie, the McDonalds of Glen-
garie &and Barrisdale, the McKenzies,
Frasers &and the other absent high-
landers shou’dshould conveenconvene, these be-
ing a great part of the Flower of
the Prince’s Army. It was argued,
that engaging wtwith Regulars so ad-
vantageously posted &and compleatlycompletely
form’dformed, &and so far superioursuperior in Num-
bers was a very desperate &and unad-
visable Attempt. That there were
not above✝ 5000 of the Highland
Army on the field, whereas the other
Army consisting of 15 Regiments of
Foot &and of Horse, besides a part
of Loudon’s Regiment, the Camp-
bells &and other Volunteers cou’dcould not
be much under 10000, &and was given
out to be 15000 strong. That their
whole
			
			
				1276
			(1276)
			
whole Cause depended on the Issue of
this Battle, &and therefore that they ought
not to engage without some Probability
of Success. It was likewise propos’dproposed
to continue the Cannonading for some
time, untilluntil a DetatchmentDetachment, which Roy
Stuart offer’doffered to lead, shou’dshould march pri-
vately about by the Water of Nairn,
&and attack the Enemy in the Rear,
whilst the main Body advanc’dadvanced and
attack’dattacked them in front: That this wou’dwould
not only distract the Enemy, &and be apt
to throw them into Confusion, but wou’dwould
likewise deprive them in some mea-
sure of the great Advantage they
then had, by having the Wind &and Wea-
ther in their Backs, which at that
very time was exceedomg stormy.
But notwithstanding all these Overtures
&and Arguments, it was carried to attack
without Hesitation, to leave their Can-
non behind, &and to rush in Sword in hand,
as the only Chance they had to dis-
comfit the Regulars, whom they had so-
often defeated in that Way. The Prince
was quite ✝ against fighting, &and the only
time it was that ever he appear’dappeared
to be of that Opinion. But he behoov’dbehooved
to yield; &and accordingly Orders were given
			
given to the respective Officers, to
cause the Men keep up their fire till
they cou’dcould do certain Execution; And
then upon the first fire to throw a-
way their Guns &and attack Sword in
hand. The Highlanders were yet at
a considerable Distance, &and the Ene-
my’s Cannon playing upon them, all
the time, with Ball: But when they
came within 300 Yards, the Regulars
loaded their Cannon with Grape-Shot,
&and kept a continued running fire
of their Small Arms upon them so
long, that ‘tisit is surprizingsurprising they did no
more Execution. In advancing Lord
George Murray had inclin’dinclined a good
deal to the Right, probably to a-
void being flanked by the Dragoons;
but this occasioning a Gap towards
the left, the McDonalds were in dang-
er of being surrounded, which made
them stop, till the Duke of Perth’s
&and Glenbucket’s Regiments were
drawn forward from the 2d Line to
make up the Line. Mean timeMeantime the
right, being batter’dbattered with Cannon &and small
Arms in the front, &and by the Campbells
from the Park-dyke in the flank, fell
into Disorder &and went off; &and suffer’dsuffered more 1278 (1278)
more in their Retreat than they did
in advancing. The✝ Center of the
Highlanders at the same time fell
in with a part of the Enemie’sEnemy’s left,
brokeX Barrel’s Regiment, &and drove all
before them &and took☂ two of their Can-
non. But the right Wing having fled,
&and the left having stoptstopped till the two
Regiments above mention’dmentioned shou’dshould
come up, another Regiment came
up to the support of Barrel’s, &and the
Center of the Highlanders was al-
most surrounded. Then all went to
			
wreck.
			that had been sent to hasten their
joining the Prince at Inverness, the
ClannsClans were at that Time so scat-
ter’dscattered, that it was Monday ✝night the
14th ‘ere the Camerons arriv’darrived at
the Camp. And of them came only
about half the Number that had ap-
pear’dappeared at Falkirk, it being impossi-
ble to get such of them as liv’dlived in
the Neighbourhood of Fort-William
to turn out, till that Place shou’dshould be
reduc’dreduced. On Tuesday Keppoch’s Mack-
donalds came up as much reduc’dreduced in
Proportion, as the former. Clan-rannald
had but a mere handful of his People.
Clunie* was still in Badenoch with about 800
Lord Cromarty in Sutherland; as were
the McGreggors, the McKinnons, &and a Party
of the McDonalds with Barrisdale;
And the half of the Frazers were only
on their March with their young Chief,
at the very time of their Engagement.
So that ‘tisit is certain the Prince wanted
upwards of 2000 of his very best High-
landers ev’neven upon Tuesday evening
when his Army was at the best. How-
ever, upon Monday Night, he order’dordered
them to form, &and rest
[
&and about Culloden-Parks, while the
Artillery &and Ammunition was brought carried
out of Inverness. Upon Tuesday Mor-
ning, the whole Army was drawn
up to Culloden Muir, &and there form’dformed
in Order of Battle, consisting of a
Front &and second Lines, with a small
Reserve. All the Men seem’dseemed to be
in great Spirits expecting the Ene-
my ev’ryevery Moment. The Prince (who
was dress’ddressed in a Tartan Jacket &and Buff
Vest) rode with his AidAide-de-Camps
from right to left, &and address’daddressed each
different Corps with a chearfulcheerful Smile
&and Salute, while they return’dreturned with
loud Huzzas, especially when any
of the Scouts came in with ^an AllarmAlarm/;
And the AllarmAlarm was given several times, 1269 (1269)
times, on purpose to animate them.
Thus pastpassed the Tuesday, till towards
the Evening, when a general Coun-
cil of War was call’dcalled, in which,
after Xsome Disputes, it was re-
solv’dresolved to march all Night &and attack
the Enemy in their Camp at Nairn,
wcwhich was ^at about✝ ten Miles Distance.
It was agreed upon, that the Army
shou’dshould be divided into two Columns;
the one consisting of the ClannsClans,
commanded by Lord George Murray,
was to advance about a quarter
of a Mile before the other, in order
to surround φ Town of Nairn, &and
form their Attack on the East &and
North Sides of the Duke’s Camp:
Whilst the other Column, consist-
ing of the French &and Low-land Re-
giments, commanded by the Duke
of Perth, was to attack them upon
the South &and West Sides, all at one
time. The Night was dark &and some-
what foggy, which no doubt gave
great Numbers an Opportunity to
desert: And the Ground through
which they march’dmarched was very rough
&and unev’nuneven. However they went on,
till the first Column
[
289
]
Miles of the Duke’s Camp, when all
of a sudden they were order’dordered to
wheel about &and return to Culloden.
Who, ✝or what it was that occasion’doccasioned
this unlucky Retreat, I shall not
pretend with any Certainty to deter-
mine. But common Report, &and ev’neven
the best Authority I have yet met
with fixes it upon XLord George
Murray. Some alledgeallege, that the Co-
lumn he commanded had gone a
little out of the Way; &and that being
afraid he shou’dshould not be able to reach
the Enemy before Day-light, he
advis’dadvised with the Gentlemen who com-
manded under him, &and gave it as
his Opinion that they shou’dshould retreat
to which ‘tisit is said they unanimously
agreed. ‘TisIt is likewise said that they
heard the Dragoons at Auldearn, two
Miles east-ward of Nairn beating
their Drums for Saddles &and Bridles,
which they took to be an Allarmalarm in
the Duke’s Camp. Others give out
that Lochiel was the first who pro-
pos’dproposed their marching back, on account
of the great Desertion he found among
his
X 
				
				
				1271
			(1271)
			As to the
			
Mistakes &and Aspersions thrown out agtagainst LdLord G:George Murray,
see this Affair cleared up, Vol:Volume 4. pag:pages 667, 668, &cetc. See
[th]e whole of Colonel Kerr’s Account, Vol:Volume 4. fmfrom p:page 648 to 670.
[and] yethe Letter in Vol:Volume 3. fmfrom p:pages 429 to 457.
 Mistakes &and Aspersions thrown out agtagainst LdLord G:George Murray,
see this Affair cleared up, Vol:Volume 4. pag:pages 667, 668, &cetc. See
[th]e whole of Colonel Kerr’s Account, Vol:Volume 4. fmfrom p:page 648 to 670.
[and] yethe Letter in Vol:Volume 3. fmfrom p:pages 429 to 457.
Robert Forbes, A:M:
his Men. But, be that as it will,
certain it is the Prince was ✝not con-
sulted; &and tho’though Master of his Tem-
per beyond Thousands, ‘tisit is impossi-
ble to express the Concern he was in
upon meeting the Duke of Perth’s
[
positively say that he cry’dcried out, “I
“am betray’dbetrayed; What need I give Or-
“ders, when my Orders are disobey’ddisobeyed?
He call’dcalled for the Duke of Perth, who
came soon up to him &and inform’dinformed him
that the other Column had retreat-
ed; &and that Lord George had sent
orders to him, viz the Duke of Perth,
to return to Culloden. He was ve-
ry keen for sending Orders to Lord
George to return, but being told,
that Lord George was already so
far on his Way back that it wou’dwould
be impossible to bring up the Army
time enough to execute the intend-
ed plan, he said with an audible
Voice “‘TisIt is no Matter then; We shall
meet them &and behave like brave
Fellows. So back they march’dmarched, &and
arriv’darrived at Culloden about sev’nseven o’
Clock in the Morning. The fatigue
of this night's march join’djoined to the want of
the want of food, occasion’doccasioned a prodigious
murmuring among the private Men, ma-
ny of them exclaiming bitterly ev’neven in the
Prince’s hearing, which affected him ve-
ry much. Many of them fell asleep in
the Parks of Culloden &and other Places
near the Road &and never waken’dwakened till
they found the Enemy cutting their
Throats. Great numbers of them went
to Inverness &and other adjacent Places to
look for some Refreshment: So that
when certain Intelligence was brought
of the Enemy’s being hard at hand,
I’m assur’dassured there were not above a
thousand Men ready to appear on the
Field of Battle: And this oblig’dobliged them
to draw up about a ✝quarter of a Mile
farther back than they had done the
Day before, &and on a much less conve-
nient Spot of Ground. Such as were
at a Distance acted as their different
Inclinations led them; many of them,
no doubt endeavour’dendeavoured to provide for
their Safety by slipping off as fast
as they cou’dcould, whilst the rest hurried
to the field of Battle. About twelve o’
Clock the Lines were brought to some
confus’dconfused form. On the right of the front-
Line, were the Athole Brigade, Came-
rons &and Stuarts, commanded by Lord George
Murray
Kintoshes, Farquharsons, McLeans, Mc-
Laughlans, &and Chisholms, commanded
by Lord John Drummond. And on the
left, were the Frasers &and McDonalds
of Keppoch &and Clan-rannald comman-
ded by the Duke of Perth. The second
Line, commanded by Roy Stuart, was
made up of Lowlanders, French,
Perth’s &and Glenbucket’s Regiments;
And the Reserve of Ogilvie’s. The
Right Wing was flank’dflanked by the Life
Guards, &and the Left by the Hussars,
which except 40 or 50 ^French Dragoons
ill-mounted, was all the High-
land Cavalry. But quite different
was their Appearance this Day, from
what it had been the Day before.
The Men were nodding with Sleep
in their Ranks, &and at least 1500 ^fewer in
Number. Ev’nEven the Prince himself, in
spite of all his Endeavours to the
contrary, was not able to conceal
that Damp which his last night’s
Disappointment had cast upon his
Spirits. And it is said, that he strong-
ly suspected his Designs had miscar-
ried thro’through Treachery. — On the other
hand, the Duke’s Army posted them-
selves on an advantagiousadvantageous ground, making 1274 (1274) making three Lines, cover’dcovered with Cannon
in the front, &and Dragoons on the right &and
left. They had likewise a Reserve of
Dragoons, &and some of these with the
Campbells had taken Possession of
a Park upon the High-lander’sHigh-landers’ Right,
in order to flank them either when
they shou’dshould advance or retreat. Some
of Stoniewood’s Regiment assert, that
Colonel Baggot had advis’dadvised to post
them along the outside of that Park-
dyke, which probably wou’dwould have pre-
vented a good deal of Mischief
these Campbells &and Dragoons afterwards
did; but✝ that Lord George Murray wou’dwould
not hear of it — Both Armies being now
within Cannon-shot of one another
the Highlanders took off their Bonnets,
&and gave a great Shout, which the Ene-
my answered with a huzza. Then
the Prince’s Cannon fir’dfired thrice from
Right to Left before the Duke’s, but
did little or no Execution, only the
Dragoons on the Left were observ’dobserved to
reel a little. Immediately after that
the Duke’s Cannon began, &and fir’dfired with-
out Intermission the whole time of
the Action: And tho’though many of the
Balls went quite over the Highland
Lines, yet there’s no doubt but such a long
good many, especially after the Can-
non were loaded with Grape-shot
which was done upon the highlanders
advancing nearer. Matters looking
thus but very gloomy, the Prince
call’dcalled a short general Council
of War, in which some propos’dproposed to
retreat a little to the Hills, till
Clunie, the McDonalds of Glen-
garie &and Barrisdale, the McKenzies,
Frasers &and the other absent high-
landers shou’dshould conveenconvene, these be-
ing a great part of the Flower of
the Prince’s Army. It was argued,
that engaging wtwith Regulars so ad-
vantageously posted &and compleatlycompletely
form’dformed, &and so far superioursuperior in Num-
bers was a very desperate &and unad-
visable Attempt. That there were
not above✝ 5000 of the Highland
Army on the field, whereas the other
Army consisting of 15 Regiments of
Foot &and of Horse, besides a part
of Loudon’s Regiment, the Camp-
bells &and other Volunteers cou’dcould not
be much under 10000, &and was given
out to be 15000 strong. That their
whole
whole Cause depended on the Issue of
this Battle, &and therefore that they ought
not to engage without some Probability
of Success. It was likewise propos’dproposed
to continue the Cannonading for some
time, untilluntil a DetatchmentDetachment, which Roy
Stuart offer’doffered to lead, shou’dshould march pri-
vately about by the Water of Nairn,
&and attack the Enemy in the Rear,
whilst the main Body advanc’dadvanced and
attack’dattacked them in front: That this wou’dwould
not only distract the Enemy, &and be apt
to throw them into Confusion, but wou’dwould
likewise deprive them in some mea-
sure of the great Advantage they
then had, by having the Wind &and Wea-
ther in their Backs, which at that
very time was exceedomg stormy.
But notwithstanding all these Overtures
&and Arguments, it was carried to attack
without Hesitation, to leave their Can-
non behind, &and to rush in Sword in hand,
as the only Chance they had to dis-
comfit the Regulars, whom they had so-
often defeated in that Way. The Prince
was quite ✝ against fighting, &and the only
time it was that ever he appear’dappeared
to be of that Opinion. But he behoov’dbehooved
to yield; &and accordingly Orders were given
✝ 
				
				1277
			(1277)
			Robert Forbes, A:M:
given to the respective Officers, to
cause the Men keep up their fire till
they cou’dcould do certain Execution; And
then upon the first fire to throw a-
way their Guns &and attack Sword in
hand. The Highlanders were yet at
a considerable Distance, &and the Ene-
my’s Cannon playing upon them, all
the time, with Ball: But when they
came within 300 Yards, the Regulars
loaded their Cannon with Grape-Shot,
&and kept a continued running fire
of their Small Arms upon them so
long, that ‘tisit is surprizingsurprising they did no
more Execution. In advancing Lord
George Murray had inclin’dinclined a good
deal to the Right, probably to a-
void being flanked by the Dragoons;
but this occasioning a Gap towards
the left, the McDonalds were in dang-
er of being surrounded, which made
them stop, till the Duke of Perth’s
&and Glenbucket’s Regiments were
drawn forward from the 2d Line to
make up the Line. Mean timeMeantime the
right, being batter’dbattered with Cannon &and small
Arms in the front, &and by the Campbells
from the Park-dyke in the flank, fell
into Disorder &and went off; &and suffer’dsuffered more 1278 (1278)
more in their Retreat than they did
in advancing. The✝ Center of the
Highlanders at the same time fell
in with a part of the Enemie’sEnemy’s left,
brokeX Barrel’s Regiment, &and drove all
before them &and took☂ two of their Can-
non. But the right Wing having fled,
&and the left having stoptstopped till the two
Regiments above mention’dmentioned shou’dshould
come up, another Regiment came
up to the support of Barrel’s, &and the
Center of the Highlanders was al-
most surrounded.
"
wreck.
Here end the two sheets of a Narra-
tive in the Hand-writing of the RevdReverend
Mr George Innes.
tive in the Hand-writing of the RevdReverend
Mr George Innes.
✝X☂ 
This, I believe, is a Mistake; for the Right
			
Wing it was (under LdLord George Murray’s Command[)]
that broke the Left of the Enemy &and took two of
their Cannon, as appears from other Accounts.
Vol:Volume 1 pag:page 160. Vol:Volume 3 pag:pages 446, 447. Vol:Volume 4. pag:pages
665, 666, 673, 674. Vol:Volume 1. pag:page 129.
Wing it was (under LdLord George Murray’s Command[)]
that broke the Left of the Enemy &and took two of
their Cannon, as appears from other Accounts.
Vol:Volume 1 pag:page 160. Vol:Volume 3 pag:pages 446, 447. Vol:Volume 4. pag:pages
665, 666, 673, 674. Vol:Volume 1. pag:page 129.
Robert Forbes, A:M:
N: B: The RevdReverend Mr George Innes was with
			
me in Leith from Thursday Night
AugtAugust 24th, to Friday Forenoon, SeptrSeptember
1st 1749. when (at my Request) he
allowed me to keep the two Sheets
of a Narrative in his own Hand-
writing above mentioned. See in
this Vol:Volume pag:pages 1280 &and 1281.
me in Leith from Thursday Night
AugtAugust 24th, to Friday Forenoon, SeptrSeptember
1st 1749. when (at my Request) he
allowed me to keep the two Sheets
of a Narrative in his own Hand-
writing above mentioned. See in
this Vol:Volume pag:pages 1280 &and 1281.
Robert Forbes, A:M:
The late Glenladal told the RevdReverend D.Donald MacKintos[h]
			
that he saw the Major of the Mackintoshes a gun sho[t]
past the enemy’s cannon at Culloden muir
				that he saw the Major of the Mackintoshes a gun sho[t]
past the enemy’s cannon at Culloden muir
The majorsmajor’s name was John MacGilivrae
Citation
Forbes, Robert. “Copy of a Letter from the Reverend Mr. George
            Innes, March 15. 1748/9, and of a narrative et cetera.” The Lyon in Mourning, 
                    vol. 6, 
                    Adv.MS.32.6.21, fol. 74v–86v. The Lyon in Mourning Project, 
                    edited by Leith Davis, https://lyoninmourning.dhil.lib.sfu.ca/ v06.1254.01.html.
Appendix
In the sense of: "a piece of writing".
See Carroll's memorial, Bulloch, Families of Gordon, p. 100. According to the author of the Life of Archibald Mc'Donald of Barisdale (1754), however, Archibald MacDonell, third of Barisdale may have been responsible for carrying out the action, though his father gave the orders (p. 22).